4.8 stars from 114 Google reviews

Family, cosmetic and implant dentistry

Dr. Steven Haywood, DDS

Sedation for anxious patients

Payment plans with CareCredit and Cherry

Emergency visits

4 S. Main St, Shrewsbury, PA

A family in the waiting room at Southern York Smile CareMadi Backel caring for a patient

Southern York County

The family dentist for Shrewsbury and the towns around it

Book a visit
Call (717) 235-3871

Dr. Steven Haywood, DDS, ICOI Fellow

Minutes from New Freedom, Stewartstown and Glen Rock

Cleanings to implants, all in one office

A dentist for southern York County, PA

Southern York Smile Care is on Main Street in Shrewsbury, PA, close to home for families in Shrewsbury Township, New Freedom, Railroad, Stewartstown, Glen Rock, Loganville and Jacobus. Dr. Steven Haywood, DDS has cared for patients here for more than 35 years: cleanings and exams, white fillings, crowns and bridges, dental implants planned on a 3D scan, porcelain veneers, Invisalign, children's dentistry and sedation for anxious patients. The office is mercury-free, offers fluoride to patients who want it and a remineralization varnish to those who don't, and sees dental emergencies. New patients are welcome. You pay at the visit, the office files your insurance claim, and monthly plans are available through CareCredit and Cherry.

Everyday dental care

Smile Guide
View all

Your hometown dental office

01

Right on Main Street

4 S. Main St in Shrewsbury, minutes from New Freedom, Railroad, Stewartstown, Glen Rock and Loganville.

02

The whole family

Cleanings and checkups for everyone, with sedation for anxious patients.

03

Emergencies seen fast

Current patients are seen the same day whenever possible, and on weekends for a true emergency.

04

No referrals needed

Implants, oral surgery and smile makeovers are done in the same office.

Emergency Dental Care
Seen as soon as possible
Gum Disease Treatments
Mostly non-surgical
White Dental Fillings
Matches your tooth
All-Porcelain Crowns
Matched to your smile
Invisalign Clear Aligners
Custom-made for you
Single Tooth Implant
Looks like your own tooth
Sedation Dentistry
Health review first
The waiting room at Southern York Smile Care

Real stories, real smiles

Rated 4.8 from 114 reviews on
Google

“My husband had a tooth extraction a few years ago at another practice, the tooth was not fully removed which later caused pain and infection. Dr. Haywood was able to work on my husband as soon as possible and do diligent work with grace and care. …”

Brianna G.
Google review · September 2026

“I've had an excellent experience with Dr. Haywood and his team. I'm currently undergoing Invisalign treatment with Dr. Haywood, and the care I've received has been outstanding. Kelley at the front desk made me feel welcome with her warm and friendly attitude from my very first phone call. …”

Bold K.
Google review · July 2026

“It is not often that someone will say that that don’t mind going to the dentist.Not only is Dr. Haywood a great dentist who gave me back my smile 6 years ago, but everything about this office is great. …”

Beth R.
Google review · May 2026

“During an emergency situation with my front teeth, Dr. Haywood and the entire team were incredibly helpful. They are not only kind, but genuinely compassionate, which made a stressful experience much easier. Dr. …”

Miley K.
Google review · March 2026

“My husband & I are so pleased we were encouraged to reach out to Dr Haywood by our son. My husband has reclaimed a healthy mouth after having had a lot of misery for over a year & facing 2 extractions with the same potential problems which started all his problems. …”

Peg B.
Google review · March 2026

Patient stories

Hear it from patients of Dr. Haywood in their own words.

Map of Main Street in Shrewsbury, PA, with the office markedOpen in Maps

Visit us from New Freedom, PA

Southern York Smile Care
4 S. Main St, Shrewsbury, PA 17361
(717) 235-3871

Get directions from New Freedom, PA →© OpenStreetMap contributors

Frequently asked questions

Which towns do you serve?

Shrewsbury, New Freedom, Railroad, Stewartstown, Glen Rock, Loganville, Jacobus, Seven Valleys and the rest of southern York County.

Do you see the whole family?

Yes, Southern York Smile Care treats whole families from southern York County. Cleanings, checkups and treatment for every age, in one office.

What if I have a dental emergency?

Call (717) 235-3871 as early in the day as you can. Current patients are seen the same day whenever possible, and on weekends for a true emergency; new patients when there's an opening.

Do you offer payment plans?

Yes. Monthly plans are available through CareCredit and Cherry, with a soft credit check.

How do I book a first visit?

Call (717) 235-3871 or request an appointment online. New patients can fill in the forms online before the visit, which keeps the first appointment focused on your teeth rather than paperwork.

What are your hours?

Southern York Smile Care in Shrewsbury, PA is open Monday 8:30 AM to 6:00 PM, Tuesday 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM, Wednesday 8:30 AM to 3:00 PM, Thursday 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM and Friday 8:30 AM to 4:00 PM. The office is closed on weekends.

Do you take insurance?

Southern York Smile Care is out of network: payment is due at your visit and the office files your claim so your insurer can reimburse you. Monthly plans are available through CareCredit and Cherry.

Who will I see?

Dr. Steven Haywood, DDS, who graduated cum laude in 1987 and is a Fellow of the International Congress of Oral Implantologists, with Kelley, Madi and Scott looking after your visit and your questions.

Can my whole family come to the same office?

Yes. Children, parents and grandparents are all seen at the Shrewsbury office, so one visit to Main Street can cover the family's check-ups.

Do you offer sedation for nervous patients?

Yes: oral sedation, a pill taken before your visit, for longer treatment or stronger fear. Dr. Haywood talks it through before the day, so you know exactly what to expect and who will drive you home.

Do you place dental implants in the office?

Yes, Dr. Haywood places dental implants in the Shrewsbury, PA office. Dr. Haywood plans and places implants in Shrewsbury, from a single tooth to a full arch with All-on-4, so there is no referral across the county.

Answers for families in southern York County.

Porcelain dental crowns