4.8 stars from 114 Google reviews

Family, cosmetic and implant dentistry

Dr. Steven Haywood, DDS

Sedation for anxious patients

Payment plans with CareCredit and Cherry

Emergency visits

4 S. Main St, Shrewsbury, PA

Madi Backel laughing with a patient and her granddaughter in a treatment roomMadi Backel with a patient at Southern York Smile Care

Dentist near New Freedom, PA

Seven minutes up Route 851 from New Freedom

Book a visit
Call (717) 235-3871

Holistic and mercury-free

Grandparents to grandkids in one office

On Main Street in Shrewsbury since 1992

A holistic family dentist near New Freedom, PA

Southern York Smile Care is the dental office of Dr. Steven Haywood, DDS at 4 S. Main St in Shrewsbury, PA, about 7 minutes from New Freedom along Route 851. For families in New Freedom and Railroad it is a mercury-free, holistic office close to home: no silver fillings are placed, old ones are removed safely, fluoride is offered to anyone who wants it with a remineralization varnish for those who don't, and metal-free zirconia implants are available. Grandparents, parents and children are seen in the same office for cleanings, gum care, tooth-colored fillings, crowns, implants, Invisalign and veneers. Dr. Haywood has practiced on Main Street since 1992 and has more than 35 years of experience. The office is out of network with insurance, files your claim for you, and offers monthly plans through CareCredit and Cherry. Call (717) 235-3871.

Holistic

Smile Guide
View all

Everyday dental care

Smile Guide
View all

Why New Freedom families stay close to home

01

Next door on 851

No highway: Route 851 runs from New Freedom straight onto Main Street in Shrewsbury.

02

Mercury-free and holistic

No silver fillings are placed, and old ones can be removed safely behind a barrier with strong suction.

03

Three generations

Grandparents, parents and grandkids are seen in the same office.

04

Healthy gums

Cleanings and gum disease treatment that look after the whole mouth, not only the teeth.

Mercury-Free Dentistry
Tooth-colored fillings
Cleanings and Prevention
Every six months
Gum Disease Treatments
Mostly non-surgical
White Dental Fillings
Matches your tooth
Children's Dentistry
Gentle first visits
The waiting room at Southern York Smile Care in Shrewsbury, PA

Real stories, real smiles

Rated 4.8 from 114 reviews on
Google

“My husband had a tooth extraction a few years ago at another practice, the tooth was not fully removed which later caused pain and infection. Dr. Haywood was able to work on my husband as soon as possible and do diligent work with grace and care. …”

Brianna G.
Google review · September 2026

“I've had an excellent experience with Dr. Haywood and his team. I'm currently undergoing Invisalign treatment with Dr. Haywood, and the care I've received has been outstanding. Kelley at the front desk made me feel welcome with her warm and friendly attitude from my very first phone call. …”

Bold K.
Google review · July 2026

“It is not often that someone will say that that don’t mind going to the dentist.Not only is Dr. Haywood a great dentist who gave me back my smile 6 years ago, but everything about this office is great. …”

Beth R.
Google review · May 2026

“During an emergency situation with my front teeth, Dr. Haywood and the entire team were incredibly helpful. They are not only kind, but genuinely compassionate, which made a stressful experience much easier. Dr. …”

Miley K.
Google review · March 2026

“My husband & I are so pleased we were encouraged to reach out to Dr Haywood by our son. My husband has reclaimed a healthy mouth after having had a lot of misery for over a year & facing 2 extractions with the same potential problems which started all his problems. …”

Peg B.
Google review · March 2026

Patient stories

Hear it from patients of Dr. Haywood in their own words.

Map of Main Street in Shrewsbury, PA, with the office markedOpen in Maps

Visit us from New Freedom, PA

Southern York Smile Care
4 S. Main St, Shrewsbury, PA 17361
(717) 235-3871

Get directions from New Freedom, PA →© OpenStreetMap contributors

Frequently asked questions

How close is the office to New Freedom?

About 3 miles and 7 minutes. Southern York Smile Care is at 4 S. Main St, Shrewsbury, PA 17361: follow Route 851 from New Freedom and it becomes Main Street in Shrewsbury, with no highway on the way.

Is Southern York Smile Care a holistic dentist?

Yes. The office is mercury-free and never places silver fillings, removes old ones safely, and offers metal-free zirconia implants. See holistic dentistry.

Are you taking new patients from New Freedom?

Yes. Southern York Smile Care in Shrewsbury, PA welcomes new patients of every age from New Freedom and Railroad. Call (717) 235-3871 and fill in the new patient forms before your visit.

Do you see children and grandparents too?

Yes. Children, parents and grandparents from New Freedom are seen in the same office, from a child's first checkup to dental implants and dentures.

Do I have to avoid fluoride at a holistic office?

No. Fluoride is offered to anyone who wants it, and patients who prefer to avoid it can choose a remineralization varnish instead.

What are your hours?

Southern York Smile Care is open Monday 8:30 AM to 6:00 PM, Tuesday 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM, Wednesday 8:30 AM to 3:00 PM, Thursday 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM and Friday 8:30 AM to 4:00 PM. The office is closed on weekends.

Do you take insurance?

Southern York Smile Care is out of network with every insurer: payment is due at your visit and the office files your claim so your insurer can reimburse you. Monthly plans are available through CareCredit and Cherry.

Answers for patients in New Freedom, PA.

A tooth with a tooth-colored filling