Here are 4 reasons to look for the ADA Seal when you shop for toothpaste, floss, mouthwash or a toothbrush for your family. The small seal tells you the product's claims were checked by independent experts. Here is what it means and how to use it.
Shopping for oral care can feel overwhelming. One aisle can hold a hundred toothpastes, each promising whiter, stronger or healthier teeth. The American Dental Association Seal of Acceptance cuts through the noise. At Southern York Smile Care in Shrewsbury, PA, Dr. Steven Haywood, DDS, often points patients to it as a simple shortcut to products that do what they say.
What the ADA Seal of Acceptance is
The ADA Seal is a voluntary program run by the American Dental Association. A company that wants the seal on its product has to apply and send in scientific evidence that the product is safe and works as claimed. A panel of experts reviews that evidence. If the product passes, it can carry the seal for a set period, and the company has to keep meeting the standards to keep it.
You will find the seal on many everyday items, including toothpaste, toothbrushes, floss and other between-teeth cleaners, mouthwash and some sugar-free chewing gum. You can also search the list of accepted products on the ADA's consumer website, MouthHealthy.org.
4 reasons to look for the ADA Seal
Here is why the seal is worth a quick look every time you shop.
Reason 1: It shows the product is safe and effective
The most important thing the seal tells you is that the product has been shown to be safe when used as directed and to work for its stated purpose. A toothpaste with the seal that claims to help prevent cavities has had to show evidence that it does. That means you are less likely to waste money on something that does not work, or to use something that could harm your teeth or gums.
Reason 2: The standards are based on science
To earn the seal, companies often have to meet standards that go beyond what the law requires. The ADA looks at things like ingredients, lab tests and, in many cases, studies in people. Claims on the package must be backed up. That review is done by experts who do not work for the company selling the product, which is why the seal carries weight with dentists.
Reason 3: It is like having your dentist in the aisle with you
Most people do not have time to read research before buying toothpaste. The seal does that homework for you. When you pick a product with the ADA Seal, you are choosing something that dental experts have already checked. It is a little like having your Shrewsbury dentist or hygienist standing next to you at the store, pointing to the shelf and saying, "That one is fine."
Reason 4: It verifies claims rather than picking a favorite brand
The ADA Seal is not an advertisement and it is not a ranking. The ADA does not say one brand is better than another. Instead, the seal confirms that the specific claims on the label are supported. Two different toothpastes can both carry the seal. That leaves you free to pick the flavor, price and features you like, knowing the basic promises are backed by evidence.
How to use the seal when you shop
The seal is a starting point. These tips will help you choose well:
- Read the claim next to the seal. The seal applies to specific claims, such as fighting cavities, reducing gum inflammation or easing sensitivity. Pick the product whose claim matches your need.
- Choose soft bristles. Many toothbrushes with the seal have soft bristles, which clean well without wearing down enamel or irritating gums.
- Be careful with whitening products. Some whitening toothpastes remove surface stains, but they cannot change the natural color of your teeth. For a bigger change, ask about professional teeth whitening.
- Look at sugar-free gum. Chewing sugar-free gum after meals can help increase saliva, which helps rinse away food and acids.
- Ask about your own situation. If you have sensitive teeth, dry mouth, gum disease or a lot of dental work, the best product for you may differ from what suits a friend.
A note about fluoride
Toothpastes that carry the ADA Seal contain fluoride, which the ADA recommends for cavity prevention. Southern York Smile Care respects that patients have different preferences. Fluoride is available for patients who want it, and remineralization varnish is offered for holistic patients who prefer another way to strengthen enamel. You can read more on our holistic dentistry page.
What if a product does not have the seal?
A missing seal does not always mean a product is bad. The program is voluntary, and some companies, especially small or newer ones, never apply. Some product types are not covered at all. Still, without the seal you have to judge the claims yourself. A few questions help:
- Does the label make big promises, such as "reverses gum disease" or "heals cavities"? Be wary. No toothpaste or rinse can undo a cavity that has already formed.
- Is the product very abrasive? Charcoal powders and gritty "natural" pastes can scratch enamel and make teeth look darker over time.
- Does it contain a lot of acid or sugar? Some trendy rinses and "detox" products can soften enamel.
- Is there any real evidence behind it, or only reviews and influencer posts?
If you are unsure, bring the product to your next visit and ask. The team is happy to look at the label with you.
Good products work best with good care
Even the best toothpaste and floss work only when they are used every day. Brush twice a day for two minutes, clean between your teeth once a day, limit sugary snacks and drinks, and keep your regular checkups. Our preventive dentistry page explains what happens at those visits, and every cleaning at Southern York Smile Care is a full 60 minutes. For more tips, read 10 terrific tooth tips from our team.
When home care is not enough
No product on a store shelf can fix a cavity, a chipped tooth or a missing tooth. If you would like to improve how your smile looks, Dr. Haywood offers cosmetic dentistry such as porcelain veneers, tooth-colored fillings and whitening, along with dental implants to replace missing teeth. If dental visits make you nervous, sedation dentistry with oral sedation can help you relax.
Ask us which products are right for you
Bring your questions, or even your toothpaste, to your next visit. Southern York Smile Care is at 4 S. Main St in Shrewsbury, PA, and serves York, southern York County and northern Baltimore County, MD. Call (717) 235-3871 or request an appointment.
DDS cum laude 1987, US Air Force residency, NYU cosmetic training and Fellow of the International Congress of Oral Implantologists, with 35+ years in practice.
Meet Dr. Haywood →
Porcelain Veneers and Instant Orthodontics for Shrewsbury
Don’t Use your Teeth as Tools!
Biological Dentist